How We Score Mobile Wallets

Mobile wallets aren’t new to crypto anymore. They’ve gone from niche tools for early adopters to mainstream apps downloaded by tens of millions. For a lot of people, their first taste of “self-custody” doesn’t happen on a Ledger, or in some hardcore desktop client. It happens on their phone.

And here’s the kicker. The way people judge mobile apps is very different from how they rate desktop software, exchanges, or services. Scroll through App Store or Google Play and you’ll see glowing ratings in the hundreds of thousands. Scroll through Trustpilot or Capterra? You’ll see a handful of low scores, usually from people who lost money or couldn’t get support.

Neither picture is wrong, but neither is the full story on its own. That’s why we built the Be Crypto Safe Benchmark. A way to cut through the noise and score wallets fairly, with a focus on what actually keeps your crypto safe.

Why Not Just Trust Reviews from one Site?

Before we dive into our benchmark, let’s talk about the elephant in the room, reviews across the mobile landscape are both shallow and deep depending where you look:

• App Stores (iOS + Android): High volume. Millions of ratings. Reflects the everyday user experience, how smooth it feels, whether it crashes, if it “just works.” Good for gauging mainstream sentiment.
  
• Trustpilot / Capterra: Low volume. Reflects edge cases. More likely to skew negative, because people rarely write a review when things go right. Not very representative for mobile crypto wallets.
  
• Community forums (Reddit, Discord, Twitter): Loud and unfiltered. Great for spotting common pain points (phishing scams, bugs, confusing UX). Not statistically rigorous, but invaluable context.

So instead of picking one, we combine signals. The Be Crypto Safe benchmark takes into account app store ratings for breadth, community chatter for depth, and technical audits, and history for trust.

The Be Crypto Safe Benchmark – How We Score Mobile Wallets

Here’s the quick view. If you only read one thing, make it this table:

 

Why These Weights Matter

Now let’s break these down properly. The TLDR gives you the gist, but crypto safety lives in the details.

Backup & Recovery (25 points)

This is the backbone of crypto safety. Lose your backup, lose your coins. It’s that simple. We put the most weight here because even the most secure wallet is useless if you can’t recover it. We look at whether a wallet relies only on a 12-word seed phrase, whether it supports advanced options like Shamir’s Secret Sharing, or whether it uses MPC/social recovery. We also consider how clear the instructions are for backups, and whether wallets encourage dangerous shortcuts like screenshots or cloud saves.

Security (20 points)

Security means more than not being hacked. We ask these questions: is the wallet open-source? Has it been audited? Does it have a bug bounty program? Has it survived real-world attacks without user funds being drained? Hot wallets are inherently riskier than hardware wallets, but some reduce risk better than others, via strong encryption, sandboxing, or phishing warnings.

Privacy & Data (10 points)

Crypto is transparent by default, but your personal footprint doesn’t need to be. We check whether a wallet leaks your IP and wallet activity via RPC providers, whether telemetry is optional or mandatory, and how easy it is to swap to privacy-friendly infrastructure. A wallet that assumes you’re fine with being tracked gets marked down.

Trust Signals (15 points)

Trust comes from time, transparency, and adoption. Has the wallet been around for years without major failures? Is its code published for anyone to review? Are audits regular and public? Does it have millions of users and a strong community presence? These are the signals that suggest the wallet isn’t going to disappear overnight.

UI/UX & Support (10 points)

Good design isn’t about pretty buttons, it’s about preventing mistakes. We look for wallets that make backups clear, transactions transparent, and approvals obvious. On support, we don’t expect a 24/7 helpdesk to recover your funds (no one can). But clear documentation, FAQs, and responsive communities matter.

Supported Assets & Interop (10 points)

Crypto is multi-chain, and wallets need to keep up. We score higher when wallets support not just Ethereum but also Bitcoin, Solana, Cosmos, and others. We also check for compatibility: does it work with WalletConnect? Can it pair with a Ledger or Trezor? Can you easily add custom tokens or networks? Interoperability matters.

Fees & Swaps (5 points)

Fees won’t make or break a wallet, but they can sting. We look at whether in-app swaps charge hidden service fees, whether spreads are transparent, and whether the wallet nudges you toward higher-cost options. A fair wallet doesn’t hide the bill.

Staking & Yield (5 points)

This is the cherry on top. We check whether a wallet lets you stake directly in-app, and whether it points you to reliable validators or sketchy third parties. Staking isn’t essential, but if it’s done well, it’s certainly a nice bonus.

How to Use the Benchmark

The Benchmark isn’t about crowning one wallet as the champion and trashing the rest. It’s about balance. A score in the 70s doesn’t mean the wallet is unsafe, it means it has strengths and weaknesses, and you need to know what those are before you trust it with serious funds.

Think of it like a safety rating for cars. A five-star car isn’t immune from crashes, but it gives you more confidence than one with no airbags. Likewise, a wallet with an 80+ score has its safety fundamentals in place, while one in the 60s might be fine for dabbling but risky for your long-term stack.

Use the Benchmark to match a wallet to your needs. Want the simplest path to staking multiple coins? Look for a high staking and assets score. Care more about privacy? Focus on that column. The Benchmark lets you pick what matters most to you.

The Final Buzz

The Be Crypto Safe Benchmark is our way of cutting through hype and complaints to show what really matters. App store reviews show you what the crowd thinks. Community chatter shows you what the sharp end of the user base worries about. Technical audits and history show whether a wallet can survive in the wild.

No wallet is perfect, but the benchmark gives you a clear, weighted score that reflects safety, usability, and transparency. When you see that score under each wallet review, you’ll know exactly how it was earned, and you’ll know what trade-offs you’re making if you choose to use it.

---

Stay safe. Stay smart. Be Crypto Safe.

Education is your best defence. Unlock member-only guides, checklists, and tools designed to protect your crypto, stay safe and be compliant.